Thursday 18th of September 2014

news blog logo
news menu leftnews menu right
strip5.gif

Somaliland: The Egal Airport Runway and What is Wrong
Sunday, 15 September 2013 18:14

Capt M OmarCapt M Omar

Somalilandsun – a Diaspora Lander and a certified airline Transport pilot and instructor Captain Mohamed Ahmed Omar shares his thoughts on the new Runway at Egal airport while offering comparisons with those from neigbouring countries

Hargeisa Airport And Its Runway Who To Blame This Fiasco

By Captain Mohamed Ahmed Omar Airline Transport Pilot

Let me share my thoughts concerning about Hargeisa airport & Ethiopian Airlines. According to IATA, ICAO & the International Air Law, Safety & security of the airplane & its passengers are the responsibility of the airplane operator which is Ethiopian Airlines.

According to that same law the responsibility safety & security of that airport falls on the shoulder of the airport operator, which is the government of Somaliland

The issue in here is that, the runway of Hargeisa airport is little short for a jet aircraft loaded with full passenger & lot of fuel in order to reach its destination also there is no fence or barrier to ward off intruders or people intend to do harm to Somaliland & this part our government has failed badly & was shortcoming.

It's standard in the world when construction is to be done in airport, it should be awarded to a contractor by bidding and that contract must be accredited & very well experienced in construction of airport & Runways also that company must pass a back ground check & must show prove on previous work that it has completed. Our government did not do that & was saying the contractor is international Chinese company & that is far from the truth and it is dishonest.

As per the international civil Aviation organization & the aircraft manufacturers who agreed to use set of data that to be based the performance & the capabilities of airplane & its called International Standard Atmosphere Pressure. (29.92 inches of mercury & 15° C at sea level). However, only and rarely will the airplane actually operate under conditions that approximate standard atmosphere. Any increase in temperature or altitude means a decrease in the aircraft's optimum performance. As we know Hargeisa airport is 4420Feet above sea level. The high elevation above sea-level causes the Air density to decreases with the increase of the temperature. Furthermore, Warm air is less dense than cold air because there are fewer air molecules in a given volume of warm air than in the same volume of cooler air.

As a result, on a hot day, an airplane will require more Runway to take off, will have a poor rate of climb and a faster approach for landing and will experience a longer landing roll, the combination of high temperature, high elevation, weight of the aircraft, & the condition of the runway produces a situation that aerodynamically reduces drastically the performance of the airplane & this part the government the Civil Aviation Authority has failed to consider into account when they were planning the renovation of the Hargeisa airport & the runway

The Somaliland government & the Ministry Civil Aviation Authority, should have known that any aircraft with two engine or more, requires to accelerate to a specific speed for takeoff, and then in case of an engine failure, be able to stop safely on that runway, if that length to stop is not available, then this can be disastrous for airplane that does not have adequate Runway, also It's inconceivable from the Civil Aviation Authority to tell the Airlines to carry Less fuel , less cargo & to operate to Hargeisa such request is dangerous, costly & not profitable to the airlines, These & the lacking of strong security system such as concrete barrier with a strong fence line along the airfield are some of the risk factors that Airline operators (companies) and pilots have to assess in order to make informed decision

Don't blame Ethiopian Airlines for not flying into Hargeisa airport, the Ethiopian airlines is commercial & private company (not government own) & they have every right to choose which country or airport they see fit for their operations, the only option open for Somaliland government & Civil Aviation Authority is to negotiate and not force any other company if they decide not to operate to Hargeisa airport. While this current government is trying hard to do good things, first it must eliminate the corrupt individual & the corruption that tarnished its image. The Somaliland government & the Civil Aviation Authority must take the responsibility of all the mistakes & the Fiasco at Hargeisa Airport, & they should implement immediate correction

Improving the situation at Hargeisa Airport

The current available runway of 2.446 km & its pot-holed has been patched Hargeisa airport needs to be competitive with the rest of the neighboring airports it must have longer Runway, with the runway marking, lighting & the standard ICAO runway sign. For safety & security it must have concrete Barrier, Trenches & fence in all the parameter of the field. The length of the runway must be extended from 2.4 KM to 3.1 or 3.2 KM which equals to approximately 10,560 feet. That will make it safer & more suitable for a large passenger jet aircraft for day or night flights in hot or cold climate to operate in Hargeisa airport. Once this is done Egal International Airport can compete with the East African airports (Insha Allah).

Comparison Hargeisa Airport to the Neighboring airports

Berbera

Runway length 13583 feet =4.14KM

Width 164 feet = 50Meter

Airport Elevation 30 feet above sea level

Hargeisa Airport

Runway length 8005 feet =2.4KM

Width 148 feet = 45Meter

Airport Elevation 4420 feet above sea level

Djibouti

Runway length 10335 feet = 3.1KM

Width 148 feet = 45 METER

Airport Elevation 581 feet above sea level

Addis Ababa

Runway length 12467 feet = 3.8KM

Width 148 feet = 45 METER

Airport Elevation 7656 feet above sea level

Mogadishu

Runway length 10335 feet =3.1KM

Width 150 feet = 46 METER

Airport Elevation 13 feet above sea level

KISMAYO

Runway length 12139 feet = 3.7KM

Width 164 feet = 50 METER

Airport Elevation 49 feet above sea level

Mohamed Ahmed Omar

Captain

Airline Transport Pilot

Certified Flight Instructor Airplane

This e-mail address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it

 

Comments

 
+1 # Hassan 2013-09-15 19:57
I am still boggled by the fact no one interested in the development of Somaliland was overseeing such a large project. This was one of the bigger tests this government had and it appears that it has failed miserably.

Thank You Mohamed for the concise review and comparison.
 
 
0 # Rageedii 2013-09-15 22:09
Simply incompetent and unexperienced contractor and co0pted government officials messed up this project. Lets hope its corrected promptly. They have to take responsibility of the consequences.
 
 
+2 # osman 2013-09-16 00:17
please be corrected the higher you go in altitude the lower the temperature and not vice versa as highlighted in the article.
 
 
+1 # cagadable 2013-09-16 12:34
Mr. Osman please don’t get confused what the captain is talking about is the airport elevation when the aircraft is on the ground “an increase of air temperature above standard (hot day) with the high elevation of the airport have a detrimental effect on aircraft performance it will need long0nway for takeoff
In the air as the airplane climbs up, the temperature decreases & above 24000feet the temperature on the negative values (minus)
 
 
+4 # Uk 2013-09-16 02:09
Well said osman.

Mistake happen, let's hope the leaders elected to serve the nation resolve this swiftly. Also increase the0nway, for capital city to have mini0nway dwarfed even by kismayo is a joke. And please remove Dahabshil logo on the signage, it makes airport look cheap.....
 
 
0 # Rageedii 2013-09-16 11:45
Yes it looks like private companies adverts always catch the eyes. I remember regional football tournament as well their names should be printed in smaller fonts.
 
 
+2 # Abdi 2013-09-16 02:18
I think both Ethiopian Airline and the co0pt Somaliland government share the blame. Ethiopian Airline should have made a thorough inspection on the airport. Why did Ethiopian Airline land a plane at Hargeysa airport if the airport doesn’t meet international airport standards? Why did they reroute the Berbera flights? I hate to say both parties are incompetent.
 
 
0 # mohamed cheers 2013-09-16 07:03
Folks...what's all these too much negative comments about the Hargeisa Airport tarmac??? If the 2.4km is no good for big aircrafts, then that should be corrected to become commercially viable. In any case, maybe Berbera would be the future Capital for Somaliland given many factors of better feasibility
features.
Cheers.
 
 
0 # mohamed cheers 2013-09-16 07:11
Berbera...fulfi lling all the features of Capital City should be think of for
the future Capital Changed from Hargeisa to Berbera.
Cheers.
 
 
0 # ali 2013-09-16 12:50
first thing firing of aviation minister is paramount and sillanyo should really pull up his socks and be a leader of somaliland not a somali clan.where were all the somalilanders who call themselves engineers?co0pt ion does exits in all human beings but we are too poor to waste any penny that comes our way.
 
 
0 # osman 2013-09-16 13:05
the fake china company is gone and the money is gone where to get several more millions to do the job right dahabshill?
 
 
+1 # Mabullah 2013-09-16 14:49
Thanks for that educational article.

As an insider with the contractor i can assure there is nothing fake or imaginary about the Chinese company.

The HGA0nway has not only been patched but two layers of ashpalt have been paved. The contract with the government was for paving the 2440m0nway, taxiway, and turning pad. The 10,000 m^2 parking area or apron was repaved by the contractor free of charge. All the0nway markings have been completed. Only the security fence remains in production as we speak.

The length of the0nway is not the fault of the contractor.

There have been promises made by Kuwait fund to pay for extension of the0nway.

Also in defense of the Ministry, the did hire a foreign consultant to write up the whole deal. To only strengthen the existing0nway and not extend it was the recommendation of consultant to my understanding. Basically they listened to the technical advice of NARCO0ICT. That was always the assumption on our side, i can't be %100 about it.
 
 
+1 # Ali dheere 2013-09-16 15:55
Thanks Mr. Insider
I beg the difference, everyone in Somaliland are aware who was the contractor is, I know Chinese & what they look like. Omani is not a Chinese but one of the family & we know how he ended up this sweet deal
As you said the0nway has been patched & Paved with two layer of asphalt, & the contractor throw freebee for paving the Apron, let me tell you as insider myself there was nothing free
The whole deal is rotten Eggs , they wasted 4.5 million dollar & what to show not much
About the consultant, come on he was getting his cut $ 1 million, & for the defense of the aviation ministry they had known the airport0nway is way too short& they should have insisted to be extended
In conclusion the Hargeisa0nway and whatever pavement they did is not worth 4.5 Million
 
 
0 # Mabullah 2013-09-16 17:17
Mr. Ali

Omani is the sole agent for the Chinese company in Somaliland. The deal was given to the contractor because on their financial soundness, experience, and ability to procure the proper equipment and human resources. A lesser contractor might have gone ban0pt in the middle of operations and the0nway would have been left half complete.

Like i said the contractor completed ALL asphalt works stipulated in the contract and the apron which wasn't included in the contract but was done in a show of good will by the contractor. You can check the tender and see if the parking area or apron was included or not in the contract price. You don't have to be an insider to know this.

You accuse ICT0NARCO of co0ption without showing any evidence, just because you don't like what they said. These international consultancy firm are 0sted by Kuwait fund to supervise the work of both HGA and BBO projects.

I see you have a problem with the price of the contract. If so please give a better estimation on how much it would cost to do that project based on your own studies and findings. Since you are an insider you should break it down for us with details about materials costs, machinery, etc.
I look forward to seeing how you get a number less than 4.4 million for the same works.
 
 
0 # Ali dheere 2013-09-16 20:16
Mr. Mabulla
Now you are splitting a hair one time its Chinese company & the next is solo agent, that part its clear there was no Chinese company nor will be it’s just a shell name It has been checked & the government can’t hide that
For the tender issue we know it all so please spear me he is been given everything just like he was born with silver spoon in his mouth

Let’s talk about the experience & the proper equipment, according to the ministry itself there was a lot of delay due to no proper equipment until they subcontracted for paver finisher. And twice the Kuwait Fund refuse to release the fund, the Ministry could come up the complete report of the work that has been done

About the consultant i did not accuse him its fact he did not come to Somaliland for vacation or to have fun, he get paid for a fee $1Millon & that is his cut. The reason there was consultant is any project financed by Kuwait fund must have a consultant agent this is not new when Kuwait fund financed Addis Ababa airport cons0ction there was consultant there too

Whether i am insider or not is irrelevant the issue facing Somaliland government & the Civil Aviation is to come out clean & explain to their citizen how everything went so bad & they have to provide remedy to the somaliland people
 
 
0 # Mohamed Abdullah 2013-09-17 11:16
Mr. Ali

I am spending way too much time responding to comments on the internet, i am afraid i might get fired for not doing real work :).
You weren't there when the chinese engineers built the hot mix plant , set up the paver and done all this important work.
The equipment took a long time to arrive from China to Berbera port. Mainly because Berbera port is not a popular destination for international freight forwarders. The asphalt paver you talk about arrived at the same time the hot mix plant did. The Kuwait fund never refused to release any funds. Since they only pay the contractor for the works completed or materials brought to site.

I am glad you cleared that issue about the consultant. I don't know how much they were paid and can't comment. Either way the consultant of course has to get paid to do their work and that work doesn't include covering up for anyone's Their duty is mainly towards Kuwait fund to ensure the money is used properly.

The MoCA has communicated with the public it's works and showed the great success Egal international has been so far. Some people are so cynical they can never accept that something good can ever happen to Somaliland.
 
 
+2 # A.Hamza 2013-09-17 14:26
Mr.Mohamed Abdullah

Not everybody in here is aviation expert, & every citizen of Somaliland has a God given rights to speak & criticize his government when he0she see fit,I see that you have knowledge about aviation & whole lot of information about Hargeisa airport, & that is very good, I want you the explain to me & the rest of Somaliland citizen without dismissing anyone who writes positive or negative about the contractor or the government
what is the pavement Classification number of Hargeisa airport please give as the numbers for the Apron & for the0nway as per ICAO Annex 14 Aerodrome design .( ACN-PCN) Aircraft classification Number – Pavement Classification Number, please educate us will the Apron (parking ). Taxiway & the0nway in Hargeisa airport is utilized as taxiway. Can it support Boeing 737-800 series with Maximum Takeoff weight? give us precise data of pavement classification
 
 
0 # mohamed Khalid 2013-09-19 23:14
737 its possible to rotate meaning to climb up and to 108 degrees right I have done that with 757
 
 
0 # mohamed Khalid 2013-09-19 23:19
apply the brake set engine power that gives them more power to takeoff that's stander take off for short0nway. Some airline have there own guide for takeoff.
 
 
0 # waqoyi geeljire 2013-10-15 15:55
Dear Mr mohamed abdullah,
before you start calling people fools, everyone has a right to their own views
be they good or bad right or wrong..
If you want to help change those views and inform the interested people out there refrain from insults and stick to informative facts..
Now as for your work and self-proclaimed
insider Mr A Hamza asked just a few of the questions that actually need asking and answering by the people of Somaliland to the men in office in Hargesia...
 

This content has been locked. You can no longer post any comment.

Bridging Investment Gap in Somaliland

Email: growth@guulgroup.com

Website: www.guulgroup.com

You are not alone

We have 289 guests online

Salaama logo

For details visit Salaamfinancial

Ila-maqal sb




>